The Hundred Schools of Thought
In the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods, the Zhou kings had lost their authority and the rulers of the states competed for supremacy. As each state sought able men regardless of birth to grow rich and strong, thinker after thinker appeared, asking how a state should be governed and how people should live. Together they and their schools are called the “Hundred Schools of Thought.” Confucianism, Daoism, Legalism and the other ideas born here became the foundation of Chinese politics and culture for more than two thousand years, and deeply influenced all of East Asia.
The Hundred Schools at a glance
- When
- The late Spring and Autumn period to the Warring States period (6th–3rd centuries BC).
- The name
- “The masters” are the many thinkers; “the hundred schools” are their many schools.
- Main schools
- Confucianism, Daoism, Legalism, Mohism, the Military school, the Diplomatists, the Yin–Yang school and others.
- Why then?
- With the authority of the Zhou kings gone, rulers fighting for survival sought able men regardless of birth.
- Afterward
- Qin adopted Legalism and unified China; from Emperor Wu of Han on, Confucianism became the orthodox learning of the state.
A lineage map of the schools
The thinkers of the five main schools, arranged by period. As Han Fei and Li Si of the Legalists came from among Xunzi’s pupils, the schools were linked by teacher–pupil ties and by criticism of one another.
The five main schools
Confucianism
Confucius, Mencius, XunziGovernment by virtue, through benevolence (ren) and ritual (li)
Confucius took the rites and music of the early Zhou as his ideal and taught government by virtue: rule by gentlemen who had cultivated ren, a caring regard for others, and li, the ritual forms that give it shape as social order. In his lifetime he traveled from Lu to other states seeking office but was never given real power, and in old age he devoted himself to teaching. His sayings and deeds were compiled by his disciples as the Analects.
In the Warring States period Mencius held that human nature is good and argued for the “kingly way” of ruling by virtue rather than force; he even held that a ruler who oppresses the people loses the mandate of Heaven and may rightly be replaced. Xunzi, by contrast, taught that human nature is selfish and must be corrected by education and the norms of ritual. Through his pupils Han Fei and Li Si, this view led into Legalism.
“What you do not wish for yourself, do not do to others.” — Analects
Daoism
Laozi, ZhuangziNon-action and naturalness — give up contrivance and follow nature
Laozi called the source of the cosmos and all things the Dao (“the Way”) and held that the artificial morality and institutions the Confucians preached were themselves the cause of strife. A ruler should do nothing superfluous (wuwei, non-action) and leave the people to their natural ways; his ideal was a small state with few people living simply. Whether Laozi existed, and when, is unclear, and the Laozi is thought to have taken shape over a long time at many hands.
Zhuangzi taught that distinctions such as good and bad, beautiful and ugly, life and death are merely relative, seen from a human standpoint, and described in many fables a free life bound by nothing. Their thought is called “Lao–Zhuang” philosophy; in the early Han it was used in government as “Huang–Lao” thought, and later, merged with popular belief, it became one of the sources of the Daoist religion.
“The highest good is like water.” — Laozi
Legalism
Shang Yang, Han Fei, Li SiRule by law, with strict rewards and punishments
The Legalists held that a state should be governed not by the ruler’s virtue or the people’s morals but by laws applied equally to all, with strict rewards and punishments. Shang Yang, serving Duke Xiao of Qin, pushed through reforms such as mutual responsibility among households and ranks granted for military merit, turning Qin from a backward western state into a great power.
At the end of the Warring States, Han Fei perfected Legalist thought by combining Shang Yang’s “law” with “technique” for controlling ministers and the ruler’s “authority.” Impressed by his writings, King Zheng of Qin (the future First Emperor) invited him, but according to the Records of the Grand Historian he was brought down by his fellow student Li Si and died in prison. As the First Emperor’s chancellor, Li Si built Legalism into the institutions of a unified state: commanderies and counties, standard script, weights and measures, and the burning of the books.
Mohism
MoziUniversal love and opposition to aggressive war
Mozi criticized Confucian love as “love with distinctions” that favored family and those of similar rank, and preached jian’ai — loving all people equally. He opposed wars of aggression (“against attack”) and rejected the lavish funerals and music prized by the Confucians as burdens on the people.
The Mohists were not just a school of thinkers but a tightly disciplined organization, and specialists in defense who would rush to small states under attack to direct the defense of their walls. In the Warring States they were a major force, paired with the Confucians as “Ru and Mo,” but after the unified empires of Qin and Han they declined rapidly and all but disappeared.
“Promote what benefits the world, and remove what harms it.” — Mozi
The Military school
Sun Wu (Sunzi), Sun BinWin without fighting — thinking about war rationally
The Military school analyzed victory and defeat not as fate but rationally, from conditions such as intelligence, terrain, supply and morale. The Art of War of Sun Wu, said to have served King Helü of Wu at the end of the Spring and Autumn period, held that the best strategy is to make the enemy yield through diplomacy and stratagem before any fighting.
Sun Bin of the Warring States, said to be Sun Wu’s descendant, defeated Wei at the Battles of Guiling and Maling as strategist of Qi. His treatise was long lost until bamboo slips were found in 1972 in a Han tomb at Yinqueshan in Shandong, reappearing after two thousand years. The Art of War is still read as a business book, and in Japan the warlord Takeda Shingen’s banner, “Swift as the wind, silent as the forest, fierce as fire, immovable as the mountain,” comes from one of its lines.
“Know the enemy and know yourself, and in a hundred battles you will never be in peril.” — The Art of War
Confucians, Daoists, Legalists and Mohists compared
| Confucianism | Daoism | Legalism | Mohism | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ideal government | Government by virtue and ritual | Government by doing nothing (wuwei) | Government by law and reward and punishment | Government by universal love and frugality |
| View of human nature | Mencius: good; Xunzi: bad | Drop contrivance and live in harmony with nature | People seek gain and fear punishment | Everyone can love one another |
| Attitude to Confucians | — | Morality is artificial and breeds strife | Virtue cannot govern a state | Criticized their “love with distinctions” |
| Adopted by | Every dynasty from Emperor Wu of Han | Early Han (Huang–Lao thought) | Qin | Never adopted by a state |
Other schools
Su Qin, Zhang Yi
Zou Yan
Gongsun Long, Hui Shi
Xu Xing
Lü Buwei
What became of the Hundred Schools
The age when “a hundred schools contended” ended with Qin’s unification. The competition between ideas was settled by which school the state adopted.
- 4th c. BCScholars are gathered at the Ji Gate of Linzi, the Qi capital; the schools debate at the “Jixia Academy.”
- 356 BCShang Yang’s reforms: Legalist policies make Qin a great power. More
- 221 BCQin, having adopted Legalist thought, unifies the realm.
- 213 BCThe burning of the books: writings of schools other than Legalism are suppressed. More
- 134 BCOn Dong Zhongshu’s proposal Confucianism becomes the orthodox learning of the Han (the so-called adoption of Confucianism as state doctrine). More
- 2nd c.At the end of the Eastern Han the Way of Great Peace and the Way of the Five Pecks of Rice spread, and the Daoist religion, absorbing Daoist thought, takes shape. More
- 12th c.Zhu Xi of the Southern Song perfects Neo-Confucianism, later the official interpretation for the civil service examinations. More