Burning of Books and Burying of Scholars
On the advice of the chancellor Li Si, histories of the other states, Confucian classics and other works were burned — sparing only practical books on medicine, divination and agriculture and Qin’s own records — in an attempt to control thought and speech. The next year, according to the Records of the Grand Historian (Shiji), the emperor, enraged that magicians had failed to find an elixir of immortality, had several hundred Confucian scholars and magicians accused of criticizing him buried alive. Together these are called “burning the books and burying the scholars,” and became one of the main grounds on which later Confucian society condemned the First Emperor as a tyrant. Later exaggeration has been suggested regarding what was burned and what really happened, and the scale and nature of the events are still debated. At Lintong near Xi’an, a valley held by tradition to be where the scholars were buried survives as a historic site.
- In 213 BC, on Li Si’s proposal, books other than practical works and the records of Qin were collected from the people and burned (the burning of books).
- The next year, 212 BC, more than 460 scholars are said to have been buried alive in the capital Xianyang for criticizing the First Emperor (the burying of scholars).
- It became the main reason later ages called the First Emperor a “tyrant,” but whether those buried were really Confucians is debated.
Burning the books vs. burying the scholars
| Burning the books | Burying the scholars | |
|---|---|---|
| Year | 213 BC | 212 BC |
| Trigger | The scholar Chunyu Yue criticized the commandery system, urging a return to the old feudal order | The magicians Hou Sheng and Lu Sheng, who had been seeking the elixir of immortality, spoke ill of the First Emperor and fled |
| Targets | The Book of Songs, Book of Documents, works of the Hundred Schools and histories of states other than Qin | More than 460 scholars in Xianyang said to have broken the ban |
| Not burned | Books on medicine and drugs, divination and agriculture; books held by official scholars (boshi) for their work | ― |
| Punishment | Those who did not burn their books within 30 days were tattooed and put to labor; those who invoked the past to criticize present government were executed with their families | Buried alive |
Why was thought suppressed?
After unification, Qin was advancing the commandery system, under which the emperor directly governed the regions. But some scholars, citing old books, argued that “as under the Zhou, kinsmen should be made kings across the land.” Li Si feared that if people used old books to criticize present government, the emperor’s orders would not be obeyed. So, to make “Qin law the only standard of thought,” he sought to remove the books themselves from private hands.
Were “Confucians” really buried?
- The Shiji calls those buried zhusheng — “the scholars” — and does not say all were Confucians.
- It began with “magicians” (fangshi), who preached the arts of immortals and eternal life, deceiving the First Emperor and fleeing.
- On the other hand, his eldest son Fusu remonstrated with his father that “the scholars all study the teachings of Confucius” and was sent to the northern frontier. Confucians were very likely among them.
- The four-character phrase “burning books and burying scholars” spread later; after the Han made Confucianism the state teaching, harsher portrayals of Qin grew stronger.
What happened to the burned books?
Books in the state library were preserved, but when Xiang Yu burned Xianyang in 206 BC, many palace books are said to have been lost too. Under the Han, efforts began to recover the lost classics.
- Fu Sheng, a Qin scholar, hid the Book of Documents in a wall and in the Han passed on the 29 chapters that survived to his disciples.
- In the Western Han, classics written in old script are said to have been found inside a wall of Confucius’s old house.
- Books handed down in such different ways led to great scholarly controversies within later Confucianism.
Frequently asked questions
Updated: · Main sources: Shiji, “Basic Annals of the First Emperor of Qin” and “Biography of Li Si”