Confucianism Becomes the State Orthodoxy
When the Confucian scholar Dong Zhongshu urged Emperor Wu, in his “Three Responses on Heaven and Man,” to reject all other schools and make Confucianism alone the orthodox learning of the state, Confucianism began to establish itself as the de facto state ideology. Dong reworked Confucianism by incorporating yin–yang and Five Phases theory, and his doctrine of the correspondence between Heaven and man, linking the emperor’s rule to the will of Heaven, gave imperial power a theoretical foundation. Emperor Wu appointed Erudites of the Five Classics, and as Confucian learning came to count in the selection of officials, Confucianism changed from one school among many into the official learning supporting the state. This shift transformed the intellectual landscape of the Hundred Schools and would shape Chinese politics, society and education for nearly two thousand years. Still, diversity of learning outside officialdom did not disappear, and Daoist and Legalist methods of government remained in practical use.
- Under Emperor Wu of the Western Han, the scholar Dong Zhongshu argued that “Confucianism alone should be the learning of the state,” and Confucianism gained a special status.
- Erudites teaching the Confucian classics (the Five Classics) were appointed, and a system emerged in which those who had studied Confucianism were chosen as officials.
- Confucianism’s progress toward becoming the official state teaching continued afterward, completed in the Eastern Han. From then until the end of the Qing it was the foundation of Chinese government.
How Confucianism was chosen
- QinLegalism is favored, and Confucian scholars are persecuted in the burning of books and burying of scholars
- Early Western HanTo rebuild a war-weary country, Daoist-leaning “Huang–Lao thought,” which placed no burden on the people, is favored, strongly backed by Empress Dowager Dou, Emperor Jing’s mother
- c. 140 BCThe sixteen-year-old Emperor Wu, newly enthroned, calls for the recommendation of talented men. Dong Zhongshu’s reply is the “Three Responses on Heaven and Man” (dates such as 134 BC are also given)
- 136 BC“Erudites of the Five Classics” are appointed to teach the five Confucian classics
- 135 BCEmpress Dowager Dou, patron of Huang–Lao thought, dies, and the turn toward Confucianism strengthens
- 124 BCAn Imperial Academy (taixue) is founded in the capital with students under the erudites; those who passed its examinations could become officials
Dong Zhongshu’s ideas
- Heaven and humanity are connected: If the emperor governs well, Heaven sends auspicious signs; if badly, it warns him with disasters such as earthquakes and eclipses (the theory of correspondence between Heaven and humanity).
- Unifying learning: If schools are scattered, people’s thinking will not be united. He argued that the state should not take up any learning other than the teachings of Confucius.
- Incorporating yin–yang and the Five Phases: He drew on the ideas of the Warring States yin–yang school, linking the workings of nature to politics.
| Classic | Content |
|---|---|
| Book of Changes (Yi) | A book of divination; the laws of change in nature and humanity |
| Book of Documents (Shu) | Records of the words of ancient kings and ministers |
| Book of Songs (Shi) | A collection of ancient songs |
| Book of Rites (Li) | The rules of ceremony and etiquette |
| Spring and Autumn Annals (Chunqiu) | The chronicle of Lu, said to have been compiled by Confucius |
What “state orthodoxy” really meant
Textbooks often say that “Confucianism became the state religion under Emperor Wu.” But no order banned other schools, and Emperor Wu himself relied heavily on Legalist-minded officials and governed with harsh laws. State rituals and institutions were organized on Confucian lines only from the end of the Western Han into the Eastern Han, and recent research often sees Emperor Wu’s reign as the starting point of Confucian orthodoxy.
Read next
Frequently asked questions
Updated: · Main sources: Book of Han, “Biography of Dong Zhongshu,” “Annals of Emperor Wu” and “Biographies of Confucian Scholars”; Watanabe Yoshihiro, Confucianism and China
