Shang Yang’s Reforms in Qin
Employed in Qin, a backward state in the west, the Legalist statesman Shang Yang carried out sweeping reforms grounded in strict rule of law with the full backing of Duke Xiao: ranks and land awarded for military merit regardless of birth, collective responsibility to keep order, and standardized weights and measures. The reforms denied the privileges of the old aristocracy and met strong resistance, but Shang Yang is said to have allowed no exceptions, even punishing the crown prince’s tutor. They dramatically raised Qin’s agricultural output and military strength, a decisive turning point toward the later unification of China. Yet after Duke Xiao’s death Shang Yang is said to have met a cruel end at the hands of the old nobility — a symbol of the glory and tragedy of the reformer.
- The sweeping reforms (bianfa) by which Shang Yang, serving Duke Xiao of Qin, remade the state in two rounds, in 356 and 350 BC.
- Promotion by battlefield merit rather than birth, harsh laws with collective responsibility, and encouragement of farming made Qin the strongest state.
- Shang Yang himself was executed by those he had angered, but the reforms were continued, leading to Qin’s unification about 130 years later.
What the reforms did
| Area | Reform | Aim |
|---|---|---|
| Ranks for military merit | Twenty grades of rank and land were awarded according to, for example, the number of enemy heads taken in battle. Even royals lost their privileges without merit | Open a path of advancement to the lowborn and raise soldiers’ motivation |
| Groups of five and ten | Households were grouped in fives and tens; if one member committed a crime, the whole group was held responsible. Those who reported crimes were rewarded | Make neighbors watch each other to prevent crime and rebellion |
| Encouraging farming | Those who worked hard and harvested much were excused labor service; those who became poor through trade or idleness were made slaves | Increase food and the capacity to keep fighting wars |
| Law of household division | Households with two or more adult sons had to split up, or pay double tax | Increase the number of households, and so taxes and soldiers |
| County system | Small villages were merged into 41 (some say 31) counties, governed by officials appointed by the king | Direct royal control of the regions; the origin of the later commandery–county system |
| Standard weights and measures | Units of length, volume and weight were standardized | Make tax collection fair and accurate; a forerunner of the First Emperor’s nationwide standardization |
Winning trust: “the promise of the moved log”
Before launching the reforms, Shang Yang set up a log three zhang (about 7 m) long at the south gate of the capital and announced: “Whoever moves this to the north gate will receive ten pieces of gold.” No one believed it, so he raised the reward to fifty; one man carried it. Shang Yang paid him the fifty at once, showing that “the state always keeps its word,” and only then announced the new laws.
The results of the reforms
- 361 BCDuke Xiao takes the throne and seeks talent to strengthen the state. Shang Yang (Wey Yang), from the state of Wey, comes to Qin
- 356 BCFirst round of reforms: the groups of five and ten, ranks for military merit and more
- 350 BCSecond round: the capital moves to Xianyang, and the county system and standard weights and measures are introduced
- 340 BCShang Yang defeats Wei and is granted the land of Shang, becoming known as “Lord Shang”
- 338 BCWhen Duke Xiao dies, nobles who hate him frame him for treason. At the inn where he flees, he is turned away: “By Lord Shang’s law, guests without identity papers cannot stay.” He is finally captured and torn apart by chariots
- 221 BCThe laws are not repealed but carried on, and Qin destroys the six states and unifies the realm
Read next
Frequently asked questions
Updated: · Main sources: Shiji, “Biography of Lord Shang” and “Annals of Qin”; The Book of Lord Shang
