Chinese History Timeline日本語
333 BC
Foreign Relations

Vertical and Horizontal Alliances

In response to Qin’s growing might, a dizzying diplomatic battle unfolded between the “vertical alliance” (hezong), in which the six eastern states joined to resist Qin, and the “horizontal alliance” (lianheng), in which Qin allied with individual states to divide them. Su Qin, who championed the vertical alliance, is said to have served at one time as chancellor of all six states, while Zhang Yi, advocate of the horizontal strategy, skillfully broke the alliance apart as Qin’s chancellor. Both were masters of rhetoric of the School of Diplomacy, and their maneuvering left later ages with a lasting sense of the importance of information and diplomacy, not just force. The eastern states repeatedly fell out of step, while Qin steadily grew strong enough to overwhelm them all.

In a nutshell
  1. In the later Warring States period, two diplomatic strategies competed over how to deal with the rising power of Qin in the west.
  2. The “vertical alliance” (hezong), advocated by Su Qin, was for the six states lined up north to south to join hands against Qin. The “horizontal alliance” (lianheng), advocated by Zhang Yi, was for each state to ally separately with Qin.
  3. The six states’ interests clashed, so the vertical alliance never lasted, and Qin used the horizontal strategy to divide them and take them one at a time.

Where the seven states lay

Qin (Xianyang)Han (Xinzheng)Wei (Daliang)Zhao (Handan)Yan (Ji)Qi (Linzi)Chu (Ying)
Vertical alliance (the six states linked north to south)Capitals of the Seven Warring States (approximate). Qin lay to the west; the six states lined up north to south in the east. “Zong” means north–south, “heng” east–west

Vertical and horizontal alliances

Vertical alliance
Su Qin
  • The six states ally to resist Qin
  • He urged the kings: “Better to be the beak of a rooster than the rump of an ox” (better the head of a small independent state than the servant of a great one)
  • Su Qin is said to have held the seals of chancellor of all six states at once
Horizontal alliance
Zhang Yi
  • Each state allies separately with Qin for its own safety
  • As Qin’s chancellor he traveled from state to state, breaking up their alliances
  • He tricked King Huai of Chu — “break with Qi and you will receive 600 li of land” — then later blandly said it was “six li”
Were the two really rivals?
In the Shiji, Su Qin and Zhang Yi are contemporaries and rivals who studied under the same master (Guiguzi). But texts such as the Zhanguo Zonghengjia Shu found at Mawangdui in 1973 have made the theory that Su Qin was active a generation after Zhang Yi the leading view.

Why Qin won

  • The six states’ interests diverged: Han and Wei, near Qin, were constantly attacked, while distant Qi and Yan felt little danger. The six states also fought each other over territory.
  • The weakness of the allied armies: The allied armies of the six states attacked Hangu Pass several times, but out of step, they were repulsed every time.
  • Befriend the distant, attack the near: A strategy advocated by Qin’s chancellor Fan Ju: ally with distant states and attack nearby ones — a development of the horizontal strategy.
  • Bribery and subversion: Qin sent money to senior ministers in other states and undermined them from within, for example getting Zhao to kill its great general Li Mu.
Year (approx.)Event
c. 333 BCSu Qin is said to have organized the vertical alliance of the six states (the Shiji’s dating)
318 BCAn allied army of Han, Zhao, Wei, Yan and Chu attacks Qin but is defeated
313 BCZhang Yi tricks Chu into breaking its alliance with Qi
241 BCThe last allied army attacks Qin and fails
230–221 BCQin destroys the six states one after another and unifies the realm

Read next

Frequently asked questions

What were the vertical and horizontal alliances?
Diplomatic strategies of the Warring States: the “vertical alliance” had the six states ally against Qin, the “horizontal alliance” had each ally separately with Qin. Today the phrase is also used for shifting alliances made and broken according to interest.
What does “better the beak of a rooster than the rump of an ox” mean?
That it is better to be the head of something small than to follow at the back of something large, doing as you are told. It is said to be what Su Qin told the King of Han to win him to the vertical alliance.

Updated: · Main sources: Shiji, “Biography of Su Qin” and “Biography of Zhang Yi”; Strategies of the Warring States; the Mawangdui silk manuscript Zhanguo Zonghengjia Shu

Key Figures

Su Qin
A diplomatist of the Warring States who advocated a vertical alliance of the six states against Qin and is said to have served as chancellor of all six at once.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Zhang Yi
A diplomatist who served Qin, advocating the horizontal strategy of separate alliances to divide the other states, in rivalry with Su Qin’s vertical alliance.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)