The Tyranny of King Zhou
Zhou, said to be the last Shang king, doted on his consort Daji, indulged in “lakes of wine and forests of meat” and put remonstrating ministers to cruel punishments — long told as the archetypal tyrant. Yet many of these tales come from later texts, especially sources of the Zhou who overthrew the Shang, and may exaggerate the victors’ view of the vanquished. Recent research also points to an able ruler who actively campaigned against peoples in the east, and the simple tyrant image is being reconsidered. His story was retold again and again in later fiction such as Investiture of the Gods (Fengshen Yanyi) and still appears on screen today.
- King Zhou (Di Xin), the last Shang king, is said to have been infatuated with his consort Daji and to have thrown the state into chaos with luxury and cruel punishments.
- Through stories such as “lakes of wine and forests of meat” and the paolao punishment, he has been held up as the worst tyrant in Chinese history.
- But much of this is thought to be exaggeration by the Zhou, who overthrew the Shang, and by later books. The oracle bones also reveal an able king who poured his energy into campaigns against the Yi peoples in the east.
The misdeeds attributed to King Zhou
| Story | What it says |
|---|---|
| Lakes of wine and forests of meat | He filled a pond with wine and hung meat from the trees like a forest, holding all-night feasts with naked men and women running about |
| The paolao punishment | He heated an oiled bronze pillar over a fire and made prisoners walk on it, laughing with Daji as they fell into the coals |
| The death of Bi Gan | To his uncle Bi Gan, who remonstrated, he said, “They say a sage’s heart has seven openings — I want to see,” and had his chest cut open |
| Jizi and Weizi | His uncle Jizi feigned madness and became a slave; his elder brother Weizi left the state |
| The Deer Terrace | He built a tall tower to hoard treasure and burdened the people with heavy taxes |
Was he really a tyrant?
- Ruined the state by doing whatever Daji said
- Became a byword for tyranny with King Jie of Xia — “Jie and Zhou”
- The later the period, the more stories of his misdeeds appear
- Even Zigong, a disciple of Confucius, said, “Zhou’s wickedness was not so great as this. All ill repute flows downstream” (Analects)
- Oracle bones record Di Xin making large-scale campaigns against the Renfang and others in the east
- While his main forces were turned east on these campaigns, the Zhou seem to have attacked from the west
It is common in Chinese histories for the victorious dynasty to portray the last king of the defeated one badly. To explain that “the Mandate of Heaven passed from the Shang, which had lost its virtue, to the Zhou,” the Zhou needed to emphasize King Zhou’s wickedness.
Read next
Frequently asked questions
Updated: · Main sources: Shiji, “Annals of Yin”; Biographies of Exemplary Women; Han Feizi; oracle-bone studies
