Chinese History Timeline日本語
1004
Foreign Relations

The Treaty of Chanyuan

When the Liao emperor Shengzong and his mother Empress Dowager Xiao personally led a great army south to the river opposite Chanzhou (present-day Puyang, Henan), close to the Song capital Kaifeng, panic spread at the Song court, with some even urging that the capital be moved to escape. But the chancellor Kou Zhun strongly urged Emperor Zhenzong to take the field himself, and when Zhenzong appeared on the walls of Chanzhou, Song morale soared; the Liao general Xiao Talin was shot dead beneath the walls, and the situation tipped slightly in the Song’s favor. The two states then made peace: Song and Liao became “brother states” on equal terms, and the border was fixed as it stood, with the Song sending Liao 100,000 taels of silver and 200,000 bolts of silk every year as “annual gifts” (the Treaty of Chanyuan). Sometimes called humiliating, the treaty in fact bought some 120 years of peace and lively trade for a relatively small economic burden, and is sometimes praised as a precedent of pragmatic diplomacy.

In a nutshell
  1. The peace treaty concluded in 1004 between the Northern Song and the Liao (Khitan) at Chanzhou (Chanyuan).
  2. In exchange for the Song sending Liao 100,000 taels of silver and 200,000 bolts of silk every year, the border was fixed as it stood, and the two states were to deal with each other as brothers.
  3. For about 120 years afterward there was no major war between them, establishing the Song diplomatic pattern of buying peace with money.

The road to the treaty

  1. 979 and 986
    Emperor Taizong of Song attacks twice to recover the Sixteen Prefectures, and is crushingly defeated both times
  2. Autumn 1004
    Shengzong of Liao and his mother Empress Dowager Xiao march south with a great army of about 200,000, reaching Chanzhou north of the Yellow River
  3. Alarm at court
    At the Song court, some urge fleeing south to Jinling or west to Chengdu. The chancellor Kou Zhun strongly insists that the emperor go to the front himself
  4. Eleventh month, 1004
    Zhenzong arrives at Chanzhou and mounts the city tower, and the Song army is greatly heartened. Before this, the Liao commander Xiao Talin had been killed by a Song crossbow bolt
  5. Twelfth month, 1004
    With Liao wanting to avoid a long war and the Song wanting to end the fighting quickly, interests align and the treaty is concluded

Terms of the treaty

ItemContent
Annual paymentsThe Song sends Liao 100,000 taels of silver and 200,000 bolts of silk every year
BorderThe present border (around the Baigou River) is kept, and neither side builds new walls or forts
RelationshipBrother states, with the Song emperor as elder brother and the Liao emperor as younger (since Zhenzong was older than Shengzong)
OtherNeither side harbors fugitives from the other
300,000
Annual payments (100,000 taels of silver + 200,000 bolts of silk)
About 120 years
Period without major war between Song and Liao
Under 2%
Share of the payments in Song annual revenue (estimate)

How should the treaty be judged?

The view that it was humiliating
  • Though winning on the battlefield, the Song paid money to make peace
  • It meant giving up on recovering the Sixteen Prefectures
  • It set a precedent of buying peace with money, later with Western Xia and Jin too
The view that it was wise
  • The payments were far cheaper than the cost of war
  • Through trade at border markets (quechang), the Song is even said to have earned more than it paid
  • During the long peace, the Song economy and culture (printing, ceramics, urban culture) developed greatly
A new form of relations between equal states
Chinese dynasties had usually treated their neighbors as “vassals.” In the Treaty of Chanyuan, Song and Liao fixed a border and exchanged envoys in a relationship close to equality. It is regarded as a form of diplomacy rare in East Asia, resembling modern treaties between states.

Read next

Frequently asked questions

What was the Treaty of Chanyuan?
The peace concluded in 1004 between the Northern Song and the Liao. In exchange for the Song sending silver and silk every year, the border was fixed and the two kept the peace as brother states.
Did the Song lose out in the Treaty of Chanyuan?
The annual payments were far cheaper than the cost of war, and there were trade profits too, so the leading view today is that the real burden was small.

Updated: · Main sources: History of Song, “Annals of Zhenzong” and “Biography of Kou Zhun”; History of Liao, “Annals of Shengzong”; Long Draft Continuation of the Zizhi Tongjian

Key Figures

Kou Zhun
Northern Song chancellor who, during the Liao invasion, strongly urged Emperor Zhenzong to take the field, bringing about the Treaty of Chanyuan and laying the foundation for some 120 years of peace between Song and Liao.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)