The Proscription of Factions
From the mid-Eastern Han, a succession of child emperors entrenched a pattern in which imperial in-laws and eunuchs took turns holding power, and upright officials and students of the Imperial Academy began to speak out. Calling themselves the “pure stream” and condemning the eunuchs as the “muddy stream,” they provoked eunuch slander that led to two waves of persecution, in 166 and 169, in which critical officials and scholars were imprisoned, executed or banned from office for life. The ban barred them from office permanently and is said to have extended to their disciples and relatives. The persecution drove from politics the healthy officials who might have corrected eunuch corruption, and the Eastern Han government lost its capacity for self-correction. It is regarded as a key factor in the deepening unrest that led to the Yellow Turban Rebellion and the rapid decline of the dynasty.
- In the later Eastern Han, eunuchs serving at the emperor’s side came to run the government, and Confucian-educated officials and students fiercely criticized them.
- In 166 and 169 the eunuchs arrested their critics as “partisans” (dangren), killing some and banning others from office for life (the Proscription of Factions).
- With conscientious intellectuals shut out of politics, the Eastern Han government could not recover, leading to the Yellow Turban Rebellion of 184.
Eunuchs versus intellectuals
- With a run of child emperors, eunuchs close to the emperor gained power
- In 159 they helped Emperor Huan overthrow the in-law Liang Ji, winning great power
- They made their relatives and acquaintances officials, and bribery spread
- Criticized eunuch corruption and called themselves the “pure stream”
- The Imperial Academy in the capital had 30,000 students who traded judgments of people’s character (“pure criticism”)
- Led by Li Ying, Chen Fan and others
The two proscriptions
- 166A diviner friendly with the eunuchs predicted “an amnesty is coming soon” and had his son commit murder. Even after the amnesty was issued, Li Ying executed the son
- First proscription (166)The eunuchs charged that “Li Ying and others have formed a faction with the students and are slandering the court,” and more than 200 including Li Ying were arrested
- 167They were released but sent home under a lifelong ban on holding office (jingu)
- 168Emperor Ling takes the throne. The in-law Dou Wu and Chen Fan try to remove the eunuchs, but the plot leaks and they are killed instead
- Second proscription (169)More than 100 including Li Ying are killed, and 600–700 are banned or exiled. In 176 even the relatives of partisans are barred from office
- 184When the Yellow Turban Rebellion breaks out, the ban is finally lifted for fear the partisans would join the rebels
The wounds it left on the Eastern Han
- Political corruption: With no critics left, under Emperor Ling official posts were even sold for money.
- The power of local notables: Those banned taught in their home districts and won local respect. These networks of notables later became the base of talent that supported Cao Cao, Sun Quan and Liu Bei.
- A conflict repeated through Chinese history: Struggles between eunuchs and officials broke out again in the late Tang and the late Ming, weakening the dynasty each time.
Read next
Frequently asked questions
Updated: · Main sources: Book of the Later Han, “Biographies of the Proscribed Partisans” and “Biographies of Eunuchs”; Kawakatsu Yoshio, Wei, Jin and the Northern and Southern Dynasties