Chinese History Timeline日本語
1141
War & Conflict

Death of Yue Fei and Peace with the Jin

Yue Fei, though of peasant origins, trained an elite force known as the “Yue Family Army” through outstanding leadership, repeatedly repelled Jin armies and was said to be on the verge of a northern advance. But as a leader of the war party he clashed with the policy of Emperor Gaozong and chancellor Qin Hui, who put peace with the Jin first, and he was imprisoned on the vague charge of “something that may have happened” (moxuyou) and died in prison. The Treaty of Shaoxing concluded that year set the border at the Huai River, with the Southern Song acknowledging vassal status and sending the Jin large annual payments of silver and silk — a humiliating but long peace. Yue Fei’s death has been told ever since as the tragedy of a loyal minister destroyed by a traitor, and at the Yue Fei Temple beside West Lake in Hangzhou, kneeling statues of Qin Hui and his wife still stand — traditionally spat upon by visitors.

In a nutshell
  1. Yue Fei, a Southern Song general, led the “Yue Family Army” to defeat the Jin again and again, but at the end of 1141 (January 1142) he was executed on suspicion of treason.
  2. To Gaozong and the chancellor Qin Hui, who were pursuing peace with the Jin, Yue Fei, who would not stop fighting, was an obstacle.
  3. In the Treaty of Shaoxing the same year, the Huai River became the border and the Southern Song agreed to serve the Jin as a vassal.

Yue Fei’s path

  1. 1103
    Born to a farming family in Henan. Legend says his mother tattooed the four characters “serve the nation with utmost loyalty” on his back
  2. c. 1127
    He joins the army around the time of the Jingkang Incident and rises under Zong Ze
  3. 1134
    He recovers six commanderies, including Xiangyang, from “Qi,” a Jin puppet state
  4. 1140
    The Jin break the treaty and march south. Yue Fei defeats the elite Jin cavalry at Yancheng and reaches Zhuxianzhen near Kaifeng
  5. Seventh month, 1140
    Gaozong and Qin Hui send twelve gold-lettered tablets (the most urgent orders) in a single day ordering withdrawal. Yue Fei withdraws, lamenting, “Ten years of effort, wasted in a day”
  6. 1141
    Stripped of his command, he is imprisoned on a charge of treason
  7. First month, 1142
    He is executed in prison, aged 39. His son Yue Yun and his subordinate Zhang Xian are executed too
Portrait of Yue Fei painted in the Ming
Portrait of Yue Fei painted in the MingImage: artist unknown / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

War party and peace party

The war party
Yue Fei, Han Shizhong and others
  • The north and Kaifeng should be recovered
  • The captive Huizong and Qinzong should be rescued
  • Serving the Jin as a vassal is a national disgrace
The peace party
Gaozong, Qin Hui and others
  • Continued war would ruin the finances
  • It is dangerous for the generals’ near-private armies to grow too large
  • There is also said to have been an unspoken motive: if Qinzong returned, Gaozong’s throne would be in danger
Terms of the Treaty of Shaoxing (1141–42)
ItemContent
BorderThe Huai River in the east and Dasan Pass in the west
HierarchyThe Southern Song serves the Jin as vassal, and its emperor is invested by the Jin
Annual tribute250,000 taels of silver and 250,000 bolts of silk sent to the Jin every year
OtherGaozong’s mother Empress Dowager Wei and Huizong’s coffin are returned to the Southern Song

“Moxuyou” and later judgments

There was no firm evidence for Yue Fei’s crime. When General Han Shizhong pressed Qin Hui, Qin is said to have replied, “Moxuyou” — “something that may have happened.” The phrase still means a trumped-up charge today.

  • In 1162 the next emperor, Xiaozong, restored Yue Fei’s good name, later granting him the posthumous name “Wumu” and then the title “King of E.”
  • At the Yue Fei Temple beside West Lake in Hangzhou, iron statues of Qin Hui and his wife and others kneel before Yue Fei’s tomb.
  • Yue Fei became, like Guan Yu, a “hero of loyalty,” celebrated in the novel The Complete Story of Yue Fei and in Peking opera.
  • On the other hand, under the Qing — descendants of the Jurchen Jin — and in modern China as a multiethnic state, there has been cautious debate about calling him a “national hero.”

Read next

Frequently asked questions

Why was Yue Fei killed?
Because to Gaozong and the chancellor Qin Hui, who were pursuing peace with the Jin, Yue Fei, who wanted to keep campaigning north, was an obstacle. The charge was treason, without clear evidence.
When was Yue Fei executed?
On the 29th day of the 12th month of the 11th year of Shaoxing — January 27, 1142, in the Western calendar. The timeline uses 1141, the year the peace was made.

Updated: · Main sources: History of Song, biographies of Yue Fei and Qin Hui; Jianyan Yilai Xinian Yaolu

Sites & Buildings

Yue Fei Temple
Yue Fei Temple
A temple to Yue Fei beside West Lake in Hangzhou. Kneeling statues of Qin Hui and his wife in its grounds remain objects of visitors’ condemnation.
Photo: Morio / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Key Figures

Yue Fei
Southern Song general who never stopped calling for resistance to the Jin, but was executed by the peace party; later deified as the embodiment of “serving the nation with utmost loyalty.”
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Qin Hui
Southern Song chancellor who led the peace with the Jin and is held to have sent Yue Fei to his death on false charges; ever since a byword for treason.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)