Chinese History Timeline日本語
208
War & Conflict

Battle of Red Cliffs

Having nearly unified North China, Cao Cao pushed south, took Jing Province and pressed on across the Yangtze to unify the realm — but the alarmed Sun Quan allied with Liu Bei, who had been driven from Jing Province, to resist him. Cao Cao’s army was vastly larger but reportedly suffered from unfamiliar river warfare and an epidemic, and when Huang Gai, under Zhou Yu, approached feigning surrender and set fire ships loose, Cao Cao’s fleet anchored on the Yangtze was thrown into chaos and devastated. Cao Cao was forced to retreat north, and his ambitions in the south were thwarted. Cao Cao held the north, Sun Quan the Jiangnan region and Liu Bei Jing and later Yi Province — the turning point that fixed the tripartite division of Wei, Wu and Shu. In Romance of the Three Kingdoms the battle is one of the great showcases of Zhuge Liang’s and Zhou Yu’s strategies, and it continues to have an enormous influence on Chinese culture.

In a nutshell
  1. The battle in 208 in which the allied forces of Sun Quan and Liu Bei defeated Cao Cao’s great army — on the verge of unifying the realm — at Red Cliffs on the Yangtze.
  2. The key to victory was a fire attack by Huang Gai, Zhou Yu’s subordinate. Cao Cao’s army was not used to fighting on boats and was also suffering from an epidemic.
  3. This defeat put Cao Cao’s unification out of reach and fixed the shape of three kingdoms — Wei, Wu and Shu — standing side by side.

The road to battle

  1. 200
    Cao Cao defeats Yuan Shao at the Battle of Guandu and takes the lead in North China
  2. 207
    Cao Cao defeats the Wuhuan in the north, nearly unifying North China. Liu Bei wins over Zhuge Liang with “three visits to the thatched cottage”
  3. Seventh to ninth month, 208
    Cao Cao marches south. Liu Biao of Jing Province dies of illness, and his successor Liu Cong surrenders without a fight
  4. Around the ninth month, 208
    Fleeing south, Liu Bei is overtaken by Cao Cao’s cavalry at Changban and badly beaten. He escapes to Xiakou
  5. The alliance
    Zhuge Liang goes to Sun Quan to urge an alliance. In Wu, where the case for surrender was strong, Zhou Yu and Lu Su argue for war, and Sun Quan decides to fight
  6. Winter 208
    The armies clash at Red Cliffs

Comparing the forces

Cao Cao’s armySun Quan–Liu Bei allied army
StrengthHe claimed 800,000. Zhou Yu estimated it at 150,000–160,000 northern troops plus some 70,000–80,000 surrendered Jing Province troops30,000 Wu troops under Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu, plus about 10,000 each under Liu Bei and Guan Yu and under Liu Qi
StrengthsOverwhelming numbers; he had also taken over Jing Province’s fleetExperienced in fighting on boats on the Yangtze
WeaknessesWorn out by a long campaign, the northern troops suffered from seasickness and disease. The surrendered Jing troops were not truly loyalFew troops, and nothing to fall back on if they lost

Why did Cao Cao lose?

  • The fire attack: Zhou Yu’s subordinate Huang Gai advised: “Cao Cao’s ships are linked bow to stern; set them on fire and they cannot escape.” Feigning surrender, he approached with boats loaded with dry grass soaked in oil and set them alight.
  • The wind: A strong wind spread the fire, burning even the camps on shore.
  • Disease: An epidemic had spread through Cao Cao’s army, leaving many soldiers unable to fight. Cao Cao himself later wrote in a letter that “because of the epidemic, I burned the ships and withdrew.”
  • Unfamiliar country: Soldiers from the north were not used to the southern climate or to fighting on water.

Official history vs. Romance of the Three Kingdoms

Red Cliffs is the greatest showpiece of the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and many of its famous scenes are the novel’s inventions or embellishments.

SceneOfficial historyThe Romance (novel)
Zhuge Liang summons the southeast windNot recordedHe prays at an altar and raises the wind
Collecting 100,000 arrowsNot recorded (based on a different anecdote about Sun Quan)Boats of straw dummies catch the enemy’s arrows
Pang Tong’s chained-ships ruseNot recordedHe gets the ships chained together so they cannot escape
Huang Gai’s self-injury ruseThere is a feigned surrender, but no beating sceneHe lets Zhou Yu beat him to make the surrender believable
Heroes of the fire attackZhou Yu and Huang GaiZhuge Liang’s role is greatly enlarged

After the battle

  • Cao Cao withdrew by the Huarong road and went back north, leaving troops to hold Jiangling.
  • Zhou Yu took Jiangling after a year-long fight, but died of illness in 210 at 36.
  • Liu Bei gained four commanderies in southern Jing Province, then took Yi Province (present-day Sichuan) and built up his power.
  • In 220 Cao Pi founded Wei, in 221 Liu Bei founded Shu and in 229 Sun Quan founded Wu — the Three Kingdoms period.

Frequently asked questions

Where was the Battle of Red Cliffs fought?
On the middle Yangtze; the leading theory places it around present-day Chibi City, Hubei. There have long been several theories about the site.
Who won the Battle of Red Cliffs?
The allied forces of Sun Quan and Liu Bei. The main fighting was actually done by the Wu army led by Sun Quan’s commander Zhou Yu.
Did Zhuge Liang really summon the wind?
No. The wind-summoning scene is an invention of the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The histories record that Zhuge Liang persuaded Sun Quan and brought the alliance together.

Updated: · Main sources: Chen Shou, Records of the Three Kingdoms, “Annals of Emperor Wu” and biographies of Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang (with Pei Songzhi’s commentary)

Sites & Buildings

Red Cliffs Battlefield Site
Red Cliffs Battlefield Site
The traditional site of the battle in Hubei, with inscriptions carved into the cliff; now developed as a tourist site.
Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA)

Key Figures

Zhuge Liang
Strategist and statesman who served Liu Bei. Famed for his brilliant intellect, he has been remembered ever since as a byword for wisdom.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Cao Cao
One of the warlords at the end of the Eastern Han and founder of the Wei state’s foundations; a statesman, strategist and noted poet.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Zhou Yu
Renowned Wu general who served Sun Ce and Sun Quan. He commanded the Wu forces at Red Cliffs and repelled Cao Cao’s great army.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Lu Su
Senior Wu minister and strategist who early on envisioned a three-way division of the realm and pursued the alliance with Liu Bei that paved the way to victory at Red Cliffs.
Wikimedia Commons (public domain)