Is Story of Yanxi Palace historically accurate?
Story of Yanxi Palace (Yanxi gonglüe, 2018, 70 episodes) is set in Qing, 1736–1766. Here we compare its characters and story with the historical record.
The heroine Wei Yingluo is modeled on Empress Xiaoyichun (Lady Weigiya), a consort of the Qianlong Emperor and mother of the Jiaqing Emperor. The main consorts, such as Empress Fucha and the Step Empress, are real, but most of the revenge-driven story is invented. The real Lady Weigiya rose no higher than Imperial Noble Consort in her lifetime; the title of empress was conferred posthumously, after her son was named crown prince.
How accurate is it?
| Criterion | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Real main characters | ◎ | the Qianlong Emperor, Empress Fucha, the Step Empress and the heroine’s model are all real |
| Main events | △ | the palace intrigues and the heroine’s revenge are mostly invented |
| Chronology | ○ | big events such as the empress’s death and the Step Empress cutting her hair broadly follow history |
| Characterization | △ | the sources say almost nothing about personality, so most characterization is invented |
◎ largely historical · ○ broadly historical · △ largely invented. Ratings are this site’s rough guide.
Historical background
The reigns of the Kangxi, Yongzheng and Qianlong Emperors, known as the “Prosperous Age of Kang–Yong–Qian,” were the height of the Qing. Enthroned in 1735, the Qianlong Emperor reigned for about sixty years and brought Qing territory to its greatest extent with the conquest of Xinjiang. The drama is set in the first half of his reign, in the inner palace of the Forbidden City in Beijing, where consorts ranked from empress down through imperial noble consort, noble consort, consort, concubine and noble lady competed for the emperor’s favor and their children’s standing.
Were the characters real?
In history: 1727–1775. Said to have come from a booi family of the Imperial Household Department. She rose from noble lady to Concubine Ling, Consort Ling and Noble Consort Ling, and after the Step Empress’s fall became Imperial Noble Consort and head of the inner palace. She bore many children, including the future Jiaqing Emperor.
In the drama: The story of a woman who enters the palace to uncover the truth about her sister’s death and defeats her enemies by cunning is invented. Almost nothing in the sources reveals her personality.
In history: The Qianlong Emperor’s first empress, who died in 1748. Said to have loved simplicity and to have been close to the emperor. She lost both her sons in childhood, and died of illness on the way back from an imperial tour of Shandong.
In the drama: In the drama she is the heroine’s protector, and her death is staged dramatically. In history she died of illness on the way back from the tour.
In history: After serving as Consort Xian and Noble Consort Xian, she became Imperial Noble Consort after Empress Fucha’s death and empress in 1750. On the southern tour of 1765 she cut her own hair — in Manchu custom a sign of mourning, and a grave taboo — and was sent back to Beijing and in effect deposed. She died the next year, 1766, without the funeral rites or posthumous title of an empress.
In the drama: The drama makes her the center of the palace intrigues. Why she cut her hair is not recorded; the motive the drama gives is its own interpretation.
In history: Sixth emperor of the Qing (1711–1799). Unwilling to reign longer than his grandfather Kangxi, he abdicated in favor of the Jiaqing Emperor in 1796 but held real power as retired emperor until his death. He boasted of his “Ten Great Campaigns” and is also known for his poetry and art collecting.
In the drama: The story centers on his romances and maneuverings with the consorts; politics and campaigns hardly appear.
In history: Empress Fucha’s younger brother. Trusted by the Qianlong Emperor as a Grand Councillor, he led armies in the Jinchuan campaigns and the Burma campaign. He died in 1770.
In the drama: His romance with the heroine is invented; no record links the two.
In history: There is no corresponding real person. Fuheng’s real principal wife is said to have been a Lady Nara.
In the drama: A character original to the drama.
Where the drama departs from history
The heroine’s “revenge” is invented
Empress Fucha’s death
She never became empress in her lifetime
The romance with Fuheng
Why the Step Empress cut her hair
What really happened next (spoilers)
The Step Empress died in 1766 without an empress’s funeral. No new empress was named, and Lady Weigiya, as Imperial Noble Consort, headed the inner palace until her death in 1775 at the age of 49. In 1795 the Qianlong Emperor named her son Yongyan crown prince and posthumously made her Empress Xiaoyichun; in 1796 Yongyan took the throne as the Jiaqing Emperor. The Qianlong Emperor died in 1799 and was buried in the Yu Mausoleum (Eastern Qing Tombs) with Empresses Xiaoxianchun and Xiaoyichun.