Is The Long Ballad historically accurate?
The Long Ballad (Chang ge xing, 2021, 49 episodes) is set in Tang, 626–630. Here we compare its characters and story with the historical record.
The heroine Li Changge is fictional — the daughter of Crown Prince Li Jiancheng, killed in the Xuanwu Gate Incident. The events in the background, such as the Xuanwu Gate Incident, Li Yuan’s revolt at Youzhou and the struggle with the Göktürks, are historical. In history Li Jiancheng’s sons were all killed right after the incident, and there is no record of a daughter plotting revenge.
How accurate is it?
| Criterion | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Real main characters | △ | Li Shimin and his ministers are real, but the heroine Li Changge and the hero Ashile Sun are fictional |
| Main events | ○ | the Xuanwu Gate Incident, the revolt of Li Yuan, Prince of Lujiang, and the conflict with the Eastern Göktürks are historical |
| Chronology | ○ | the order of early Tang events broadly follows history |
| Characterization | △ | the relationships around the heroine are almost entirely invented |
◎ largely historical · ○ broadly historical · △ largely invented. Ratings are this site’s rough guide.
Historical background
In the Tang, founded by Li Yuan (Emperor Gaozu) in 618, the crown prince Li Jiancheng clashed with Li Shimin, the second son, who had done much to found the dynasty. In 626 Li Shimin killed his elder brother Li Jiancheng and younger brother Li Yuanji at the Xuanwu Gate in Chang’an and soon took the throne as Emperor Taizong. To the north, the nomadic Eastern Göktürk khaganate was at the height of its power and threatened the newly enthroned emperor. The drama portrays this turbulent time just after the Tang’s founding.
Were the characters real?
In history: There is no corresponding real person. The histories record that Li Jiancheng’s five sons were killed in the Xuanwu Gate Incident.
In the drama: A crown prince’s daughter who survives and, disguised as a man, seeks revenge — the whole setup is invented (the original is a manhua by Xia Da).
In history: Second emperor of the Tang (r. 626–649). He took the throne after killing his brothers in the Xuanwu Gate Incident and, governing with an ear to the criticism of ministers such as Wei Zheng, built the stable era known as the “Reign of Zhenguan.”
In the drama: He appears as the heroine’s uncle and enemy; there is no record of Taizong clashing with a niece.
In history: There is no corresponding real person. The royal clan of the Eastern Göktürks was the Ashina; the “Ashile tribe” is an invented name that recalls it.
In the drama: His role as a prince of a steppe tribe is an invention of the drama (and manhua).
In history: Named in the histories as a son of Taizong’s famous minister Wei Zheng, though almost nothing of his life is known.
In the drama: His role as the heroine’s childhood friend who loves her is invented.
In history: A member of the Tang imperial family who governed Youzhou. Close to Li Jiancheng, he raised troops at Youzhou after the Xuanwu Gate Incident but was betrayed and killed by his subordinate Wang Junkuo.
In the drama: The revolt and Wang Junkuo’s betrayal follow history; the heroine’s involvement in it is invented.
In history: Both were Li Shimin’s close advisers and took part in planning the Xuanwu Gate Incident; later they were celebrated together as the great chancellors of the Zhenguan era.
In the drama: Their scenes pursuing the heroine are invented.
Where the drama departs from history
Li Jiancheng’s daughter is fictional
Li Yuan’s revolt is historical
The “Ashile tribe” and the Eastern Göktürks
What really happened next (spoilers)
Emperor Taizong stabilized the realm by relying on ministers such as Fang Xuanling, Du Ruhui and Wei Zheng. In 630 the great general Li Jing defeated the Eastern Göktürks and captured Illig Qaghan, and the northern nomads hailed Taizong as “Heavenly Khan.” His reign, known as the “Reign of Zhenguan,” was held up as a model of government for centuries.