Is Royal Feast historically accurate?
Royal Feast (Shang shi, 2022, 40 episodes) is set in Ming, 1417–1426. Here we compare its characters and story with the historical record.
The heroine Yao Zijin is fictional, a woman official of the Palace Food Service, which cooked for the court. The hero, Imperial Grandson Zhu Zhanji, later the Xuande Emperor, is real, as are his grandfather the Yongle Emperor and his first consort Hu Shanxiang. The Palace Food Service itself really existed in the Ming palace, but the story of cooking and love is almost entirely invented.
How accurate is it?
| Criterion | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Real main characters | △ | Zhu Zhanji, the Yongle Emperor and Hu Shanxiang are real, but the heroine Yao Zijin is fictional |
| Main events | △ | the palace-cooking story is invented; parts of the background, such as Zhu Gaoxu’s revolt, are historical |
| Chronology | ○ | the succession from the Yongle Emperor to the Xuande Emperor broadly follows history |
| Characterization | △ | the romance-centered characterization is invented |
◎ largely historical · ○ broadly historical · △ largely invented. Ratings are this site’s rough guide.
Historical background
Having seized the throne from his nephew in the Jingnan campaign, the Yongle Emperor sent Zheng He on his voyages to the southern seas, campaigned against the Mongols, and in 1421 moved the capital to Beijing. Envoys from many lands visited the newly built Forbidden City, and inside the palace the “Six Services” of women officials, such as the Palace Service and the Food Service, supported the lives of the empress and consorts. The drama covers the last years of the Yongle Emperor up to the accession of his grandson Zhu Zhanji.
Were the characters real?
In history: No corresponding real person can be identified.
In the drama: The heroine who aims for the top of the Food Service with her cooking talent and falls in love with the imperial grandson is original to the drama.
In history: 1399–1435. A favorite of the Yongle Emperor, he was named imperial grandson early. He took the throne in 1425, and his reign and his father’s are known together as the “Rule of Ren and Xuan.” He is also known for his love of painting and cricket fighting.
In the drama: His love affair with a woman cook is invented. His known historical consorts are Hu Shanxiang and Lady Sun (later Empress Sun).
In history: Zhu Zhanji’s first principal consort, who became empress after his accession. She had no son, and in 1428 was made to give up her position as empress, with Lady Sun becoming the new empress.
In the drama: In the drama she appears as a woman official; in history it was her elder sister, Hu Shanwei, who is said to have served as one.
In history: Third emperor of the Ming (r. 1402–1424). He seized the throne in the Jingnan campaign, moved the capital to Beijing and sent Zheng He on his voyages. He died in 1424 on the way back from a campaign against the Mongols.
In the drama: He is portrayed as a stern but loving grandfather watching over his grandson.
In history: The Yongle Emperor’s second son. He contended for the throne with his elder brother (the Hongxi Emperor), and in 1426, the year after his nephew the Xuande Emperor took the throne, he rebelled and was crushed.
In the drama: His role as Zhu Zhanji’s antagonist follows history.
Where the drama departs from history
The heroine is a fictional palace official
Hu Shanxiang’s background
Zhu Zhanji’s consorts
What really happened next (spoilers)
When the Yongle Emperor died in 1424 his son the Hongxi Emperor succeeded, but died within a year, and in 1425 Zhu Zhanji took the throne as the Xuande Emperor. The next year he personally put down the revolt of his uncle Zhu Gaoxu. In 1428 he set aside Empress Hu Shanxiang and made Lady Sun empress. The Xuande Emperor died in 1435 at the age of 38, and his nine-year-old son Zhu Qizhen (Yingzong) took the throne — the same Yingzong who was captured by the Mongols in 1449 in the Tumu Crisis.