Is Qin Dynasty Epic historically accurate?
Qin Dynasty Epic (Da Qin fu, 2020, 78 episodes) is set in Warring States and Qin, 259–221 BC. Here we compare its characters and story with the historical record.
The hero is Ying Zheng, king of Qin — the First Emperor himself. From his birth in Handan through Lü Buwei’s dominance, Lao Ai’s revolt and the annexation of the six states, it follows the events recorded in the Records of the Grand Historian, making it highly faithful to history. Dialogue, the characters’ inner lives and the finer details of their relationships, however, are heavily dramatized.
How accurate is it?
| Criterion | Rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Real main characters | ◎ | Ying Zheng, Lü Buwei, Li Si, Lady Zhao and almost all the main characters are real |
| Main events | ◎ | Lao Ai’s revolt, Lü Buwei’s fall, Jing Ke’s assassination attempt and the fall of the six states follow the Records of the Grand Historian |
| Chronology | ○ | broadly as in history |
| Characterization | ○ | tends to portray the First Emperor sympathetically, as a ruler with a vision of unification |
◎ largely historical · ○ broadly historical · △ largely invented. Ratings are this site’s rough guide.
Historical background
In the Warring States period, after Zhou authority had collapsed, seven states — Qin, Chu, Qi, Yan, Han, Wei and Zhao — fought one another. Qin, strengthened by Shang Yang’s reforms, crushed Zhao at Changping in 260 BC, opening the road to unification. The next year, in Handan, the Zhao capital, Ying Zheng was born, the son of a Qin prince held there as a hostage.
Were the characters real?
In history: 259–210 BC. King of Qin at thirteen, he seized real power once he began to rule in person by removing Lao Ai and Lü Buwei. In the ten years from 230 BC he destroyed Han, Zhao, Wei, Chu, Yan and Qi, and in 221 BC unified China and took the title “emperor.”
In the drama: He is portrayed largely as an ideal ruler who cares for his people; the harsh side of his rule after unification, such as the burning of books and burying of scholars, hardly appears.
In history: A great merchant who invested in Yiren (the future King Zhuangxiang), a hostage in Zhao, helped him to the throne and wielded great power as chancellor of Qin. He had the Annals of Lü Buwei compiled. Implicated in the Lao Ai affair, he fell from power and took his own life in 235 BC.
In the drama: The treatment of the Records’ claim that he was Ying Zheng’s real father, and the way the two men’s conflict is portrayed, are dramatized.
In history: Ying Zheng’s mother. The Records say she was originally Lü Buwei’s favorite concubine. She had two children with Lao Ai, and after his revolt was moved for a time to Yong.
In the drama: The sources stress her misconduct, but the drama treats her feelings sympathetically.
In history: A Legalist statesman from Chu who studied under Xunzi. After unification he became chancellor and pushed through the commandery-county system and the standardization of script, weights and measures.
In the drama: Broadly historical; his relationship with his fellow student Han Fei and other details are dramatized.
In history: The assassin who, at the request of Crown Prince Dan of Yan, tried and failed to kill King Ying Zheng of Qin in 227 BC — famous from the “Biographies of Assassins” in the Records.
In the drama: The course of the assassination attempt follows the Records’ account.
Where the drama departs from history
Was Lü Buwei Ying Zheng’s real father?
A sympathetic First Emperor
The finer relationships are dramatized
What really happened next (spoilers)
Having unified China in 221 BC, the First Emperor extended the commandery-county system across the country, standardized script, coinage and weights and measures, and rebuilt the Great Wall — while oppressing the people with the burning of books, the burying of scholars and vast building projects. When he died at Shaqiu on a tour of inspection in 210 BC, the eunuch Zhao Gao and Li Si rewrote his will to put his youngest son Huhai on the throne. Revolts broke out everywhere, and Qin fell in 206 BC, just fifteen years after unification.